Hotel Deals on the Web? Not Exactly . . .

By ARTA President John Hawks

May 6th, 2003 - Ever had a client call up to brag about the fabulous deal he just got at Hotels.com or another travel Web site for his hotel room?

It turns out that's the exception, not the rule!

In April 2003, ConsumerWebWatch.org -- the Consumers Union affiliate that works to investigate and improve the quality of information on the Internet -- conducted a special blind test of the major online hotel booking sites. Check out these results:

1. In 130 different "queries" (booking requests), travel agent systems and other online sites beat Hotels.com 99 times!

2. These sites "are quite intolerant when the user incorrectly inputs information" (for example, "Four Points by Sheraton St. Louis Downtown" versus "Four Points by Sheraton Downtown St. Louis).

3. None of the online sites offered easy ways to obtain the lowest rates during the very first search. In all cases, users have to conduct more advanced searches to see hotel rates listed lowest to highest.

4. Even the best site in the study (Travelocity) returned the lowest rate only three times out of 10!

Here's the advice you should give your clients about Hotels.com and other online travel sites:

They're great for "dreaming" and researching options for your trip, but it's "buyer beware" when clients rely on them for reservations. After they've had fun surfing the Web for hotel ideas, you can take those ideas and run them through your proprietary computer systems (including special hotel rate programs like ABC Corporate that are built on the collective buying volume of agencies around the USA) to find the very best deals.

And, now, it's not just your word against Hotels.com -- check out the complete study at this site:

www.consumerwebwatch.org

One interesting note: The study used Sabre as the "benchmark" against which these hotel rates were compared. Sabre didn't do so well this time out -- returning the lowest rate only 15 percent of the time! However, the study correctly points out that this poor showing "does not mean that travel agencies have lost a competitive edge. Some travel agents employ a variety of tools to find the best fares and rates, both online and offline."

 

   © 2003 Kintetsu International